Variation vs. Claim: Do You Know the Difference?
In my experience, I’ve seen many heated arguments in meeting rooms between Contractors and Clients. Most of these happen because one side calls it a "Variation" and the other calls it a "Claim."
When you are working on a project as high-stakes as the Chenab Bridge, using the wrong word can lead to your file being stuck in audit for months. Let’s break it down in simple terms.
1. What is a Variation?
A Variation is a change to the original contract that is agreed upon by both the Client and the Contractor. It is usually a change in the scope of work.
The Scenario: You are building a foundation. The drawing says it needs 100 MT of steel, but a revised drawing is issued that now requires 120 MT.
The Process: Since the Client issued the new drawing, they already know the quantity has changed. You just need to submit a Variation Statement to get paid for the extra 20 MT at the existing BOQ rate.
Key Point: It is "Friendly." There is no dispute. The work is within the contract, just the quantity or design has shifted.
2. What is a Claim? (The "Disputed" Change)
A Claim is a demand for payment (or time) that the Client has not yet agreed to. It usually arises from unforeseen circumstances or a disagreement.
The Scenario: Suppose there is a strike in the region, or the Client fails to provide the site access on time. Because of this, your machinery sits idle for 10 days.
The Process: The Client isn't "ordering" you to sit idle. You are "claiming" that their delay caused you a loss of money.
Key Point: It is "Adversarial." You have to prove your loss using letters, site order registers, and photos. The Client will try to defend themselves.
| Feature | Variation | Claim |
| Agreement | Agreed by both parties. | Usually a disagreement or a dispute. |
| Origin | Change in Drawings/BOQ/Scope. | Delays, Site hindrances, or "Force Majeure." |
| Rates | Usually based on existing BOQ rates. | Often based on actual market loss or new rates. |
| Ease of Payment | Easy (Part of regular billing). | Difficult (Requires heavy documentation). |
4. What is a "BOQ Variation"?
In your BOQ (Bill of Quantities), you will often see two types of variations:
Quantity Deviation: You do the same work, but more of it. (e.g., more S50 Concrete).
Extra Items (Non-BOQ): You do a completely new type of work that was never in the list. (e.g., installing a specific Cable Anchor that wasn't mentioned).
Understanding this difference is the first step toward becoming a master of Contract Management.
Comments
Post a Comment